Shelter Island House, Shelter Island Heights

I had a pleasant stay at the hotel, with its charming atmosphere and welcoming staff. The location is great, just a short walk to Crescent Beach, which was a highlight for my family. However, the queen room we received didn’t match the online photos and needs some updates. The pool is unheated, making it less enjoyable during cooler days, and the bathroom water was uncomfortably hot. Still, the breakfast was decent and the beach amenities were a nice touch.

The Shelter Island House is a truly special place with a tranquil atmosphere and lovely grounds. The staff is exceptional, ensuring your stay is pleasant and memorable. However, some rooms could use a little updating, and the pool isn't heated, which might be a downside for some. Overall, it's a fantastic spot for families and couples alike, especially with easy access to the beach and local amenities.

My stay at this hotel was absolutely delightful! The rooms were not only modern and clean, but also very comfortable, making for a truly relaxing getaway. The friendly service from the owner, Suzanne, added a personal touch to our visit. However, the breakfast options could have been a bit more diverse. The location was perfect for beach access and exploring the island, though I did find it a little pricey for a weekend stay.

I had such a wonderful stay at Shelter Island House! The ambiance was tranquil, and the staff went above and beyond to make us feel welcome. The pool area was delightful, and breakfast was a highlight with its lovely spread. However, I found the room I stayed in didn't quite match the online pictures and could use some updates. Overall, it was a fantastic getaway, but I wish the pricing was more reasonable.

Our stay at Shelter Island House was nothing short of amazing! The cleanliness and comfort of the property made us feel right at home, while the welcoming atmosphere of the guests added to the experience. The location is simply beautiful, just a block from the beach, but we did find the dining options a bit limited. Overall, it's a fantastic getaway spot that offers great value for the experience.

We had a lovely weekend getaway at this quaint hotel. The atmosphere was friendly, and the location near Crescent Beach was ideal for some family fun. While we found the room a bit outdated and the pool unheated, the staff was pleasant, and the breakfast was decent. The pricing for our stay felt a bit steep, especially considering the room's condition.

Our stay at this hotel was fantastic! The owners were incredibly welcoming, and our room was spacious, clean, and comfortable. We thoroughly enjoyed the friendly atmosphere and had a blast at the restaurant, which offered excellent food and drinks. The only minor downside was the late availability of coffee and tea in the morning, but the lovely deck made up for it.

I had an amazing time at Shelter Island House, celebrating my birthday in a beautifully maintained space. The rooms were immaculate and very comfortable, providing a restful escape. The only slight downside was the timing of coffee availability in the morning, but overall, the fantastic breakfast and convenient pool area made up for it.

We had such an enjoyable stay! The hotel is incredibly clean and had a beautiful, tranquil atmosphere. The staff were welcoming and attentive, going above and beyond to make our experience special. There were just a couple of small issues, like wishing coffee was available earlier, but overall, we loved everything about our trip and can't wait to return.

We had a fantastic family stay with three rooms, and everyone was thrilled with both the unique room features and the great service. The only small downside was that coffee and tea were available only after 8 am, but we loved sitting on the lovely deck to enjoy our drinks. The pool area had plenty of comfortable lounge chairs, making it a perfect spot to relax.